To create our list of the best sandwiches in NYC, we meticulously visited the city’s top delis and sandwich shops to ensure our picks deliver the ultimate sandwich experience. Here’s a look at how we identified these culinary treasures:
This rigorous review process ensured that only the best made the cut—each shop offering an unforgettable sandwich experience worthy of NYC’s legendary food reputation.
Is there anything more satisfying than biting into the perfect sandwich? In New York City, where culinary excellence meets endless variety, sandwiches are more than just a quick meal—they’re an art form. From towering deli creations to innovative wraps, the city offers something special for every sandwich lover.
New Yorkers take their sandwiches seriously, and with good reason. Whether it’s the smoky, hand-carved pastrami or the crispy, freshly baked bread, the quality and craftsmanship are unmatched. Finding the best sandwich in a city with many incredible options can feel like a delicious challenge.
In this piece, we’ll explore NYC’s best sandwich spots, from the iconic Pastrami Queen to hidden gems like Wrap-N-Run and Toasties. Each location has its own story, its own specialties, and a promise to deliver an unforgettable sandwich experience.
Nestled in Midtown Manhattan, Toasties & Humbowl stands out for sandwich lovers seeking fresh, high-quality options. Known for their gourmet delicatessen-style sandwiches, Toasties pairs exceptional ingredients with quick, friendly service. Their extensive menu ranges from classic cold cuts to inventive specialty sandwiches, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors. In collaboration with Humbowl, they also offer customizable Asian bowls, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty sandwich or a healthy rice bowl, Toasties & Humbowl delivers.
Conveniently located in Moynihan Train Hall, this Pastrami Queen location is ideal for commuters and travelers craving a taste of NYC’s best deli sandwiches. Their signature pastrami sandwiches, packed with tender, flavorful meat, are the perfect grab-and-go meal. Despite being situated in a bustling transit hub, the quality remains impeccable, proving that you don’t need to sacrifice taste for convenience.
Pastrami Queen on the Upper East Side is a New York institution famous for its legendary kosher pastrami sandwiches. Every bite of their hand-carved pastrami, piled high on fresh rye bread, delivers the rich, smoky flavor that has earned them rave reviews for decades. In addition to pastrami, their menu boasts corned beef, brisket, matzoh ball soup, and other deli classics, all made with traditional recipes and premium ingredients. This is the place to go if you’re craving an authentic NYC deli experience.
Pastrami Queen’s Upper West Side location brings the same iconic flavors of their original spot to this vibrant neighborhood. Perfect for a post-museum snack or a casual meal, this location offers all the classics, from pastrami sandwiches to knishes. The Upper West Side outpost continues to honor the deli’s rich heritage, making it a go-to for locals who want to indulge in old-school deli traditions.
Just steps away from Pastrami Queen’s Upper East Side location, Wrap-N-Run Grill offers a diverse menu of wraps, sandwiches, and hearty entrees. Known for its fast service and fresh ingredients, this casual spot is a hidden gem for sandwich lovers. Their famous wraps, including the Pastrami Wrap, blend traditional deli flavors with a modern twist. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Wrap-N-Run has something to satisfy every craving.
A great NYC sandwich combines bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and thoughtful preparation. In a city that thrives on diversity, each sandwich tells its own story, reflecting the cultures and traditions that make New York unique.
One defining feature is the bread. Whether it’s a crusty baguette, a chewy bagel, or a soft hero roll, the bread sets the foundation for every bite. Quality bread isn’t just a vessel; it’s an integral part of the experience, complementing the fillings without overpowering them.
The fillings themselves are where NYC sandwiches shine. The options are endless, from classic pastrami and corned beef piled high in delis to creative combinations like spicy chicken with pickled vegetables. Each ingredient must be fresh, flavorful, and balanced to create harmony in every bite.
Another important element is attention to detail. A perfect NYC sandwich isn’t just thrown together—it’s carefully crafted with the right textures and ratios. Crunchy pickles, melty cheese, and spreads like mustard or mayo are added with care to ensure every bite is satisfying.
Finally, the environment plays a role in making a sandwich memorable. Whether you’re enjoying it from a bustling deli counter, grabbing it from a food truck, or relaxing in a cozy cafe, the atmosphere becomes part of the experience.
New York City is a melting pot of cultures, and its sandwich scene reflects this diversity with bold flavors, rich histories, and creative twists. Here are a few standout sandwiches inspired by some of NYC’s top menus, each one showcasing why this city remains a culinary mecca:
These sandwiches represent the best of NYC’s food culture, combining tradition with creativity and proving that every bite has a story in this city.
New York City’s global food scene is reflected in its incredible variety of sandwiches inspired by cuisines worldwide. These internationally influenced creations bring bold tastes and diverse ingredients, making NYC a hub for sandwich lovers seeking unique culinary experiences.
The bánh mì has gained a devoted following in NYC. Combining crusty French baguettes with traditional Vietnamese flavors, this sandwich features fillings like marinated pork, pâté, pickled vegetables, fresh herbs, and a touch of spicy chili mayo. It’s the perfect harmony of crunchy, tangy, and savory.
Middle Eastern flavors shine in shawarma wraps and pita sandwiches. Packed with spiced meats like lamb, chicken, or beef, these sandwiches are paired with toppings like hummus, tahini, pickles, and fresh vegetables. NYC’s diverse food carts and restaurants make this a widely loved option.
A torta is a Mexican sandwich packed with bold flavors. Typically served on a soft telera roll, it’s filled with options like carnitas, grilled chicken, or breaded beef, along with avocado, refried beans, lettuce, and jalapeños. These sandwiches offer a satisfying bite with plenty of variety.
Arepas are made from ground corn dough and stuffed with flavorful ingredients to create delicious sandwiches. Popular fillings include shredded beef, black beans, cheese, and plantains. NYC’s Latin American food spots make enjoying this street food staple easy.
The katsu sando is a Japanese sandwich that has become a trendy favorite in NYC. It features breaded and fried pork or chicken cutlets between soft, crustless milk bread. Often paired with a tangy katsu sauce, this sandwich is simple yet deeply satisfying.
The gyro sandwich, filled with rotisserie meat (typically lamb or chicken), tzatziki sauce, tomatoes, onions, and wrapped in warm pita bread, is a crowd favorite in NYC. It’s a go-to comfort food with a Mediterranean twist.
A great sandwich becomes even more satisfying when paired with the right drink and side. Whether it’s something light and refreshing or hearty and bold, the right combination completes the meal. Here are some classic and creative pairings to try with NYC’s favorite sandwiches:
1. Pastrami on Rye
2. Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (BEC)
3. Chopped Cheese
4. Bagel with Lox and Cream Cheese
5. Italian Hero
6. Bánh Mì
7.Cubano
8.Reuben Sandwich
Pairing sandwiches with the right drink and side complements the flavors and adds variety to the meal. Whether you’re keeping it simple or going all out, there’s a perfect combination for every sandwich.
With countless delis, cafes, food trucks, and markets, NYC is a treasure trove for sandwich enthusiasts. Here are some practical tips to help you discover the perfect sandwich in the city:
New Yorkers know their food, and locals often have favorite spots that may not show up on mainstream guides. Whether it’s a neighborhood bodega or a hidden deli, their recommendations can lead you to unforgettable finds.
For a taste of tradition, visit NYC’s iconic delis. These establishments have been perfecting sandwiches for decades and are essential to the city’s culinary history. Farmer’s markets and specialty shops can also surprise you with artisanal creations.
NYC is famous for its vibrant food truck scene. Many trucks specialize in unique sandwich creations that you won’t find elsewhere. Look for pop-up events or seasonal markets where small vendors showcase their skills.
A good sandwich starts with high-quality ingredients. Pay attention to the bread, meats, vegetables, and sauces used—many shops in NYC pride themselves on sourcing local or premium ingredients to create the best experience.
NYC is home to both timeless classics and bold, creative takes on sandwiches. Don’t limit yourself—enjoy a traditional Reuben one day and a katsu sando the next. Balancing old-school favorites with innovative flavors will give you the full NYC sandwich experience.
New York sandwiches are often generous in size, so consider your appetite before ordering. Some sandwiches are big enough to share, while others are better-enjoyed solo. Many delis also allow you to customize portions.
At the end of the day, the best sandwich is the one that satisfies your personal cravings. Trust your instincts, whether savory, spicy, or loaded with extras, and don’t be afraid to try something new.
NYC’s diversity and rich culinary history make it a sandwich paradise. Immigrants from various cultures brought their traditional foods, which have been adapted and transformed into unique sandwiches. The city’s fast-paced lifestyle also makes sandwiches a convenient and satisfying meal option.
NYC sandwiches range from budget-friendly options to high-end gourmet creations. You can grab a satisfying chopped cheese or bacon, egg, and cheese for under $10, while specialty delis might charge $20 or more for a premium pastrami sandwich. No matter your budget, there’s a sandwich for everyone in NYC.
NYC is home to many creative sandwich innovations, such as rainbow bagels stuffed with unique fillings or sushi sandwiches wrapped in seaweed instead of bread. Fusion sandwiches, like Korean BBQ tacos served as wraps, also stand out for their inventive flavors. These unusual options reflect NYC’s reputation for pushing culinary boundaries.
NYC delis often prioritize tradition and quality, serving recipes passed down for generations. They specialize in classics like pastrami on rye, corned beef, and Reubens, with generous portions and fresh ingredients. The bustling atmosphere of a New York deli is part of the experience, making it distinct from standard sandwich shops.
Yes, NYC offers many healthy sandwich options featuring whole-grain bread, lean proteins, and fresh vegetables. Many cafes and delis offer vegetarian and vegan choices, such as avocado sandwiches, hummus wraps, or grilled veggie paninis. With an increasing focus on fresh and organic ingredients, healthy sandwiches are easy to find.
NYC hosts festivals like the New York City Wine & Food Festival, where you can sample creative sandwiches from top chefs and restaurants. Pop-ups and food truck events also often feature innovative sandwich creations. These gatherings are great opportunities to explore the city’s sandwich scene in a lively, social setting.
Most NYC sandwich shops and delis are happy to customize orders based on your preferences. You can choose your bread, fillings, toppings, and sauces to create a sandwich tailored to your taste. This flexibility is one of the reasons why sandwiches remain such a popular option across the city.
Many NYC sandwich spots offer options for those with dietary restrictions, including gluten-free, vegan, and halal choices. Popular shops often have allergen-friendly alternatives like gluten-free bread or plant-based proteins. With so many food-conscious establishments, finding a sandwich that suits your needs is easy.
Food trucks bring creative, affordable, and diverse sandwich options to NYC’s streets. Food trucks often experiment with bold flavors and global influences, from lobster rolls to jerk chicken wraps. Their convenience and mobility make them a favorite for locals and tourists alike.
Sandwiches in NYC are perfect for any time of day, with options tailored to breakfast, lunch, and even late-night cravings. Morning favorites include bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches, while lunchtime brings hearty options like pastrami or Italian heroes. For late-night snacks, chopped cheese or shawarma sandwiches are popular.
382 NE 191st ST
PMB # 884858
Miami, Florida
Contact us: support@getsauce.com